Sunday, August 18, 2013

Silent Witnesses: A Sermon on Job 1-2

-->
"Job" • pen, ink & wash • by Chuck Berk; Donated by the Artist for relief 
of Tsunami and Earthquake Victims in Japan



Scripture can be found here...

I can’t say they didn’t warn me.

My clergy friends, the ones I gather with each Wednesday morning to have breakfast and discuss our preaching plans for the week. They warned me about preaching Job. They said, “Really?” They rolled their eyes.

And now, after our very slow start-up over the past two weeks, in which we listened to the opening verses, we are in it. The part they were warning me about. Here we are, with the original version of “When Bad Things Happen to Good People.” And for people of faith, people who give praise to God, the story is pretty hard to take.

To recap: Job is a man who is “blameless and upright,” who “fears God and turns away from evil.” Job is who each and every one of us is trying, hoping to be. He’s not perfect—no one is perfect but God—but truly good, on the right track.

Job is the father of ten children, who are close, who enjoy feasting together. And like any good person of faith who is also a parent, Job prays for his children. Well, he does the ancient near-eastern version of praying for them: he offers sacrifices to God, to atone for any sins they may have committed, even within the interior walls of their hearts.

And God has taken notice of Job. He turns to Ha-Satan, also known here as “Satan”—in Hebrew, the Adversary, the Opposer—and says, “Have you considered my servant Job? There is no one like him on the earth, a blameless and upright man who fears God and turns away from evil” (Job 1:8).

Now, Satan is a member of God’s heavenly court. And as I said last week, his job is to bring to God’s attention those things God may have not considered. He is the original Devil’s Advocate, trying to poke holes in God’s theories, so that God might always have the best information.

You may have noticed something about this notion of God. The notion of God that is operating in this story is that God doesn’t necessarily know everything. God has a heavenly court to help with this problem. I bring this up, because this is not our notion of God. Our understanding of who God is and how God is has evolved from this more primitive understanding. We tend to believe more in the God of Psalm 139, God to whom we can pray, “Search me, O God, and know my heart; test me and know my thoughts.” We don’t assume God needs any help with this.

God draws Satan’s attention to Job as an ideal of humanity. Here, it’s Satan who rolls his eyes. His response is to claim that Job is only good and upright because he has had it too easy, he’s soft. “You have blessed the work of his hands, and his possessions have increased in the land. But stretch out your hand now, and touch all that he has, and he will curse you to your face” (Job 1:10-11). And God replies with an answer that rocks our world.

“Very well, all that he has is in your power…” And though God initially prohibits Satan from harming Job himself physically, eventually God allows even that.

The book of Job is actually taking a pretty sophisticated stance here, one that is consistent with many contemporary Christian thinkers. It does not claim that God directly tests his faithful servant Job. It does not place the events that follow directly at God’s feet. It makes the distinction between God causing suffering and God allowing suffering. And we only have to glance at the headlines to know that this is true: at the very least, God does allow suffering. Political unrest, war, genocide, unemployment, homelessness, hate crimes, domestic violence, child abuse… the evidence is undeniable, even before we turn our attention to the ordinary, garden-variety suffering we know firsthand. God allows suffering.

God has allowed Satan to curse Job’s life and fortunes. God has allowed the suffering of this man. And what follows is heartbreaking and overwhelming.

All of Job’s herds of oxen and donkeys and sheep and camels, carried off or killed.

All of Job’s servants, killed.

All of Job’s wealth, gone.

All of Job’s children, killed.

Total devastation, leaving Job with only his wife plus a handful of friends.

And Job’s response?

Then Job arose, tore his robe, shaved his head, and fell on the ground and worshiped. He said, “Naked I came from my mother’s womb, and naked shall I return there; the Lord gave, and the Lord has taken away; blessed be the name of the Lord.”  (Job 1:20-21)

Job is not your average person of faith. Job does not do what most of us do in the face of terrible tragedy, at least not as his first response. He does not immediately ask “Why?”—the most automatic and human and understandable response. He does not rail. Not yet. He makes a kind of bare bones faith statement: Human beings come into this world with nothing, and they go out of it the same way. God took only what God gave in the first place. Let God’s name be blessed, because God is God.

But did God take it away? The first chapter tells us God did not, God merely allowed it to be taken away. But I’m going to let you in on a little secret. To Job, to you, to me, the emotional truth is: it hardly matters. Loss is loss. Pain is pain. Devastation is devastation. Whether God participated actively or passively hardly registers—it’s like having an argument over the relative merits of the different handles on knives when we’re bleeding to death. All we know is, we’re bleeding. And Job cuts through to the essential: If all the world is in God’s hands, all the world is in God’s hands. He is going to keep trusting in that, for better or for worse.

Then Job’s friends come. And here, in this moment, Eliphaz the Temanite, Bildad the Shuhite, and Zophar the Naamathite do something also very human, very automatic, and very understandable. They show up in an attempt to offer comfort. They weep, and they tear their clothes and put dirt on themselves—traditional signs of mourning. And then they sit with Job.

You’ve been that person. You’ve shown up at the bedside, or the graveside, or on the front porch, holding flowers, or a little packet of Kleenex, or a casserole. In the face of terrible loss, you’ve been that person. You know you have. But have any of us been able to do what these three do next?

They sit with Job on the ground. They sit in silence. They sit for seven days and seven nights in silence, because, as the bible tells us, Job’s suffering was so great. They say nothing because there is nothing to say. They say nothing for the exact same length of time Jews traditionally sit shiva, the intense first period of mourning after a death.

And this time of sitting in silence, bearing silent witness to Job’s suffering, is the best, and most loving, and most faith-filled thing these friends do.

It is incredibly hard to be in the presence of deep suffering. Not as hard as it is to endure deep suffering yourself, of course. That is far worse. But the experience of witnessing suffering is difficult because another completely automatic and human and understandable response to suffering is to want to make it better.

And I don’t want to deter us from our attempts to make suffering better. Do you have an opportunity to feed someone who is hungry? Definitely do it. Do you have the possibility of giving clothes to someone who will otherwise be naked or cold? Yes, of course, do it. Do you have an opportunity to help rebuild a house that was damaged in a hurricane? By all means do it. Do all these things—which traditional Christian theology calls “the corporal acts of mercy,” things that help suffering bodies to stop suffering. Do them, do them!

But the suffering of the body and the suffering of the spirit often go hand in hand. And sometimes our desire to help to ease suffering causes us to say things—things offered in love, things offered hopefully—but still things that are better left unsaid. On the Sunday immediately after our Mission Trip I mentioned a pamphlet put out by Presbyterian Disaster Assistance, “A Volunteer’s Guide to Offering a Ministry of Presence.” In that pamphlet there was a helpful list of things NOT to say… things like:

“I know how you feel…”

“I was blessed not to have been hit (by the tornado)…”

“At least you have another child…”

“He/ She is in a better place…”

“This was God’s will…”

It is one thing for Job to ascribe what has happened to God. It is one thing for a person who has suffered a tragedy to find meaning in it. And… human beings are meaning-makers, it’s in our psychological DNA. We do that. We do it all the time. Given time to heal, and to reflect, and to pray, we may well find ourselves able to say of a certain terrible situation, “This is what it meant, this is what God had in mind.” Or, we may never ever get there, no matter how hard we try. But it is another thing entirely for a well-meaning friend to try to make meaning for us. It is far, far better for friends… loved ones… neighbors… co-workers… to emulate Job’s friends in this moment of gracious, God-inspired wisdom, in which they simply sit in silent presence and witness.

And don’t worry! Job’s friends get to be imperfect friends next week, when they finally do open their mouths. But for today, in the face of unspeakable loss, they understand that it is better not to speak.

And, in case you’re wondering, there is a list of “Do’s” along with the “Don’ts” in that pamphlet… things like:

“Listen…Tune your heart, eyes, ears, mind, to the person to whom you are listening…”

“Accept all persons as they are…”

“Cry if you need to cry…”

Say things like “My heart goes out to you…” or “I am sorry for your loss…” or even nothing at all, just offer respectful, mindful presence.

My friends warned me. Job in the summertime is a challenge. But the world keeps spinning, doesn’t it, and with each turn we get to witness joys and sorrows, challenges and triumphs. There are Jobs all around us, and we have endless opportunities to be with them in their loss. And we will each take our own turns at being Job, and we will find what it is to be surrounded by friends and loved ones who care and say the right and wrong things, just like we do. It’s ok. It’s ok. I’ll let the pamphlet have the final word:

[In times of loss] you are Christ’s Hands and Feet and Eyes and Ears for the survivors. The most important gift you give them is your very presence. Your being there gives them hope, connection, and love… 


Hope, connection and love. Until that day when God stops being a silent witness, and whispers in each heart, and helps us make sense of it all. Thanks be to God. Amen.

Sunday, August 11, 2013

Big Plans: Sermon for a Baptism, on Job 1:6-12 and Ephesians 1:1-14




Scripture can be found here and here...

In the year 1785 the Scots poet Bobby Burns wrote a poem, “To a mouse, on turning up her nest with a plough.” It contains an often quoted—and misquoted—line:

The best-laid schemes o' mice an' men
Gang aft agley,
An' lea'e us nought but grief an' pain,
For promis'd joy!

I learned it, “The best-laid plans of mice and men often go astray.” Or, as others have re-interpreted it, “We plan, God laughs.” That last one is a phrase I have never liked much, because of the strong implication that God is just a little sadistic. The stand-up comedienne Tig Notaro performed a set at a comedy club in Los Angeles last August that has made stand-up history. It was recorded, and Louis CK, who said it was the most brilliant night of stand-up he’d ever seen, put it on his website for a while. In her set, Notaro shared with the audience that she had been diagnosed with breast cancer the day before. She had also been hospitalized just before that with a serious infection, and before that, had lost her mother in a freak accident, AND gone through a painful break-up—all in the space of a couple of months. In one section of her stand-up set, she had this to say.

“You know, what’s nice about all this, is that you can always rest assured that God never gives you more than you can handle. Never. Never. When you’ve had it, God goes, ‘Alright, that’s it.’  

“I just keep picturing God going, ‘You know what? I think she can take a little more.’ And then the angels are standing back, going ‘God, what are you doing? You’re out of your mind!’ And God was like, ‘No, no, no…. I really think she can handle this.’”

Which, if you think about it, feels just a little bit like our reading from Job this morning. Last week we heard about the life of joyful abundance Job was leading: Job the wealthy landholder; Job, the father of a large family, all of whom enjoyed feasting together, Job, the upright and religious man who wanted to keep his family on the right path in their relationship with God. And then, in today’s reading, one member of God’s heavenly court challenges God’s positive view of Job. And though our bibles call him “Satan” he is not really Satan as we normally think of him. This is and Old Testament context and a Hebrew word, “Ha-Satan”, which means, literally, the Opposer, or the Adversary. His job, in the heavenly court, is to challenge God, drawing God’s attention to the other side of the story. And that is exactly what he is doing here. Ha-Satan doesn’t believe Job would be all that righteous and God-fearing if all his wealth and family connections were taken from him. Ha-Satan has big plans for Job, plans that would make Tig Notaro nod her head in recognition.

For the record, I don’t believe in a God who behaves the way Notaro describes him. God is no sadist. But, wow, I can understand how someone might get that idea. All the pain. All the sorrow. All the hatred floating around our world. People want someone to take responsibility, and God seems to be a natural candidate. But in our passage from the letter to the Ephesians, we see the real character of God, and we read about God’s big plans for us. Plans that are, in fact, epic in scope, cosmic in their timelessness, and the basis for all hope and joy.

This letter describes a God who “has blessed us in Christ with every spiritual blessing in the heavenly places,” and a God who has “chose[n] us in Christ before the foundation of the world to be holy and blameless before him in love.”

Little Guy, this is about you. You! Who, at the ripe old age of approximately 6 months and a couple of weeks, can do amazing things like smile, and giggle, and grab onto fingers and squeeze them, and roll onto your tummy and onto your back again, most likely. You, Little Guy, have been blessed by God with every spiritual blessing! You are being held by one of them right now! You have been welcomed into God’s family—even before you were baptized. Even before you were born. Even before you were conceived. Even before your parents were conceived. You were welcomed into God’s family before God had created the world… ponder that the next time you’re kicking your legs because the applesauce tastes so good! Think about the beginning of the world the next time Daddy plays peekaboo with you!

OK, so Little Guy may not be so interested in all this. Not yet. But we should be. Because the same big plans God has for Little Guy are the plans God has for us. Not in the specifics…God has made us different, unique, with individual callings. Some are mathematicians, some are carpenters’ wives… some haven’t figured out just yet what they are doing with their lives. But whatever our roles and responsibilities, God has blessed us with every spiritual gift. Think of it. Every spiritual gift.

You know what that means, right? It means we have everything we need, right here, right now, to be the people God wants us to be. Now, I happen to believe this is part of a promise to us as a community, not as individuals. No one person is blessed with every spiritual gift. That is a fact. But between us? We have everything we need. And with each person who joins in this community our store of God’s blessings and gifts grows deeper and more rich.

And… we are not just some passing fancy of God’s. “Chosen before the foundation of the earth” trumps Ha-Satan’s “Let’s see how God’s beloved holds up under stress” any day. God’s love for us is eternal. God’s love for us is deliberate, planned out. For each of us, and every one of us. Including this big guy whom we are going to sprinkle with water in just a few minutes.

God has big plans for us. And… I wouldn’t presume to know what they all are, but I think I’m getting good at recognizing them when they crop up. And they come from all of us. So… in honor of the baptism of this child of God, I propose a renewal of spiritual discipline I know we already practice here UPC. I propose a renewed discipline of listening to one another. I propose a reinvigorated practice of assuming that people other than ourselves just might have God-breathed ideas on how we can be God’s people together.

So let’s listen up, at coffee hour. At the Christian Education meeting. In the parking lot as we’re walking to our cars, over lunch. Let’s listen to one another. We have been blessed with every spiritual gift. God is ready to share his big plans with us. Let’s listen. Thanks be to God. Amen.


Sunday, August 4, 2013

Abundant Life: A Sermon on Job 1:1-5 and Luke 9:10-17

-->
 
Scripture can be found here and here...

How did you eat this week? If you’re like other Americans, it was all over the map. Some of you probably had a meal or two at a table, conversing with other people and taking time to enjoy the experience. And if you were graced with a certain kind of a week—who knows?—maybe you went on a picnic! Do people still go on picnics? But for most of us, odds are, we are not eating meals the way our parents and grandparents did.

We grab a protein bar or a smoothie and get in the car.

We drive through a fast food joint and eat at our desks.

We eat at a table with another person or people, but everyone spends the meal watching a TV show or glued to the computer or checking their smart phone.

We are a society that has forgotten how to eat. We are people who are deeply hungry for more than food. We are hungry for abundant life.

And by abundant life, I don’t mean an iPad 5. I mean: a life of peace and purpose, joy and meaning, with fulfilling work and joyful play and deep relationships and service to others. But that’s just me. What’s your definition of abundant life?

For Job, a biblical figure who is more parable than history, abundant life is one in which he is “blameless and upright, one who fears God and turns away from evil” (Job 1:1b). It is also a life of significant prosperity—Job’s holdings are large. He’s the “greatest of all the people in the east,” which puts him in Oprah Winfrey or Bill Gates territory.

But the thing that moves me most about Job is this: We are told that his grown children sit down together at table, often—the brothers “hold feasts,” and invite one another and their sisters, from house to house. And Job, having raised ten children who appear to be productive members of society, doesn’t leave it there. He watches out for their spiritual well-being too. After the feasts are over, Job offers sacrifices to God on their behalf—not because he believes them to be sinful, but “just in case.”

A blameless and upright and prosperous man, striving to keep his children on the right side of goodness. This is Job’s model of abundant life.

Jesus, in our passage, provides another.

Jesus’ disciples have just returned from their mission trip, but instead of rebuilding houses, they’ve been rebuilding lives: they’ve been healing and telling people about the love of God. And Jesus listens as they tell him everything they’ve done… he wants to hear the stories, about the broken lives made whole, about the Spirit filling them with just the right words, about the demons yielding and fleeing. After he has heard the stories, he takes his disciples to a city called Bethsaida, probably on the northern shore of the Sea of Galilee. It’s pretty clear from the way this is described—it says, “he withdrew privately”—that Jesus is looking for some down time for all of them, time to regroup, to have what my daughter’s Presbyterian Camp called “TWG”—Time With God. No one, not even Jesus and his followers, can pour from an empty bucket. They are trying to take time out to fill up again, on rest, on time together, on time in prayer.

Too bad for them. Because, as I’ve mentioned, they’ve been healing people. They’ve been telling people about the love and grace of God. They’ve been doing the kinds of things that are awakening in the people all across Galilee a kind of hunger for abundant life, a hunger that has people telling their friends, and the new and bigger crowds come clamoring for more. The people follow them to their Bethsaida retreat.

And you know what Jesus does. He doesn’t turn to Peter and say, “Man, they’ve found us, let’s get out of here.” You know what he does. He welcomes the people. Of course he does. Because, thank God, he’s Jesus. He EMBODIES the welcome of God. He IS the welcome of God. He welcomes them. And he tells them about the love of God. And he heals them.

And when it’s time to eat, he feeds them. You know the story, the great Math Fail of the New Testament: Five Loaves + Two Fish = Plenty of Food for 5000 Men, Not Counting the Women and the Children.

Imagine with me what that must have been like. Imagine throwing aside your work for the day… leaving the boat and the nets by the lakeshore, and leaving the bread to rise and rise but never be baked. Leaving the laundry, leaving the fields. Leaving it all because there is someone out there who is going to tell you things you need to hear… things about God’s love for you—for YOU—and things about God’s desire for you to be healed. And then, you ARE healed. This is not hypothetical. This is happening. And at the end of it all, you are not sent away to fend for yourself on the long walk home. You are encouraged to sit in and with the great and motley company of Jesus-followers to be fed by him. And… your work still awaits you at home. The nets still have to be untangled, the bread still has to be baked. But you are changed. You are changed forever by the knowledge that your life has value, and that God wants for you, healing, wholeness. Abundant life.

There are other images in scripture of abundant life. What’s yours? And how can Jesus help you find it? Is it healing you need? You’re in the right place. Is it the opportunity to sit down at table with a gloriously diverse group of God’s children? You’re in the right place. Is it comfort? Consolation? Encouragement to get out of your rut and help change someone else’s life for the better? Again, you are in the right place. Abundant life.

At the heart of the Presbyterian understanding of abundant life is this table, the Lord’s table. Our official Directory of Worship instructs us to have the Lord’s Supper frequently enough that is will be recognized as a “regular” part of Sunday morning worship. For us, that works out to 13 times each year, because we celebrate it monthly plus on Christmas Eve. And it is to be a regular part, not just of the worship of the adult, confirmed members of the congregation, but of every baptized child, too. We don’t withhold communion until our children understand it because, for one thing, none of us on this side of heaven fully understands it. And, to use another analogy, we don’t withhold food until babies understand nutrition. The grace we receive at Lord’s Supper—the entirely free gift of God’s presence—doesn’t depend upon our understanding, thanks be to God, any more than the grace we receive at baptism depends on it. This table is about God’s grace, the grace that promises abundant life.

And our promise for abundant life does not end here. I think it’s pretty clear that the gospels present a very “here-and-now” theology of abundance: God invites us to a great feast that is based on the assumption that there is enough, and we can help to ensure that by our actions, and our caring for one another. But there is also a promise here, a promise of another great feast that is to come. At that feast, God will wipe every tear from our eyes. Death will be no more. Mourning and crying and pain will be no more.  We will sit on the grass with new-old friends and long lost loved ones, and when we rise again, not only will our hunger be satisfied—at last, and for good—but our bodies will be transformed. In that feast, God will make each and every one of us new, whole, and well, once and for always. Live abundant and eternal. This is the promise. This is our faith. Thanks be to God. Amen.



Friday, August 2, 2013

Friday Five: Quiet and Simple Edition





Today's Friday Five asks us to share five self-care strategies, for those times when you've just had a rough day.

1. I get myself to a body of water. Ocean's best, but mostly not available. So a walk or even a time of quiet sitting by the river can be incredibly restoring. Time spent in the water is good, too. A swim leaves me feeling as if anything is possible.

2. I try to listen to my body, and when I'm tired I try to rest. I have an elementary school child's disdain for bedtime, so this can take real discipline. But being well-rested is incredibly important when life becomes challenging. A special treat is the Sacred Sunday Afternoon Pastor's Nap (TM).

3. I listen to music.

4. I spend time with someone I love, and who loves me. Talking is entirely optional.

5. I laugh. This can be achieved by spending time with someone who is funny, or by watching the right movies or TV shows. Laughter is almost as restorative as sleep. Laughing until you cry can be just the ticket.

Sunday, July 28, 2013

Reflections on Healing and Hope


Scripture can be found here...


As some of you know, my daughter has recently gone through the process of having her wisdom teeth extracted. And the surgeon was really thorough, so we were given lots of printed information in advance about what to expect on the day of the procedure and in the days afterward, we had a good sense about how to prepare.

Except, when you get right down to it, it’s pretty hard to pin down the whole process of healing. Bleeding may persist for up to 24 hours. Swelling may occur immediately, and increase gradually over 24-48 hours, and maximize between 48-72 hours. Nausea may result… you get the picture.

In fact, when we started talking to other people who’d had the procedure, we heard amazing variations on stories of recovery. We heard from one person who went to camp orientation the very next day, and from another who was in pain for almost three weeks. One person was incapacitated by nausea, and another had absolutely none. One person had no swelling, but remembered the pain; another had no pain but remembered the swelling (and had the pictures to prove it).

Healing is an imprecise and unpredictable process. It is as individual as, well, individuals. What is one person’s healing process is not necessarily another person’s healing process.

The same is true of communities. As many of you know, eleven of us from Union Presbyterian Church went to the Jersey Shore this past week to take part in the recovery process from the devastation of “Superstorm” Sandy. We spent a lot of our time in one particular house on Oak Street in a little beach-front community called Keansburg. A walk up and down Oak Street showed the varied pace of healing. One house was already up on stilts—homes there now have to conform to a new code in terms of elevation, or they risk not being able to have homeowners insurance. The house we were working on was in process of preparation for being raised. Another house right across the street from us looked ok on the outside, but on the inside still was filled with sand and debris from the storm. A few blocks away we saw a house that was so utterly ruined, it looked like a toy that had been stepped on. It made the heart hurt.

Our readings today show two different points of view with respect to healing. In the reading from Ecclesiastes, the writer seems to throw up his hands. All is vanity… uselessness… and days full of pain are pretty much what we can expect.

The reading from Luke’s gospel stands in powerful contrast. In it, we see Jesus, who is being pursued by people in pain because he is known to be a healer. He is known to have compassion on those with days and nights full of pain, and so people seek him out.

The two who are healed couldn’t be more different. One is a girl, a child of twelve. The other is a woman whose age is unspecified, but the nature of her ailment leads us to suspect she might be well into middle age. The younger is on the point of dying, and we have no idea how long she has been sick. The older has suffered from her hemorrhages for twelve years. The younger has family to intercede for her: her father seeks Jesus out. The older seems to be on her own, probably a result of her physical condition, which would render her a kind of untouchable in her family and community. The girl is passive, the woman is active. The girl’s father asks Jesus to heal his child; the woman reaches out to take her healing herself, by simply touching Jesus’ garment.

And… here is perhaps the most important detail. Jesus speaks directly to the woman who reaches out for healing. “Daughter,” he says, “your faith has made you well. Go in peace.” If we had only this story, the tale of the woman with the hemorrhages, we might be left with the impression that our healing is up to us. If only we had the faith, we would be healed.

But we have the other story as well, the story of the girl. She is not healed because of her faith. She is dead, past healing, past hope when Jesus comes to her. Jesus’ miraculous touch is not connected in any way to her faithfulness. If anything, it is connected to the faith of her father, someone who loves her, but even that is a stretch, because Jesus doesn’t identify it that way. As far as we can tell, it is sheer gift, sheer grace.

Healing comes when it comes. We cannot rush it. We can try not to stand in its way… not to impede or disrupt it. The only thing we know with certainty about healing is that God wills it: God wants us to be whole. But we don’t necessarily know what wholeness looks like. In our longing for wholeness we may at times feel like the writer in Ecclesiastes: that all is vanity, all is useless. But there is another witness in scripture, and that witness tells us to hope, to reach out, to seek out the healing we need. And if we aren’t able to do it ourselves, it tells us to lean on those who love us, and allow them to hope, and to reach out, and to seek on our behalf.

That is what the people in New Jersey are doing. They are working for recovery and they are leaning on the help of friends like us. Healing is an imprecise and unpredictable process. We can help one another to heal, but we have to offer our help in a way that honors the experience of those seeking healing. In closing, I’d like to share with you the wisdom of a pamphlet: It’s called “A Volunteer’s Guide to Offering a Ministry of Presence.”

As a volunteer, you are Christ’s Hands and Feet and Eyes and Ears for the survivors. The most important gift you give them is your very presence. Your being there gives them hope, connection, and love… The key is tuning your heart to the Holy Spirit and the survivor, listening with the ears of your heart, and seeing with the eyes of your heart.

In the process of healing we tune our hearts to God, and to one another. For the healing of individuals, families, communities, nations, even the world, we open our hearts with hope to the imprecise and unpredictable process that brings us closer to God’s vision of wholeness for our lives. Thanks be to God. Amen.

Sunday, July 21, 2013

The Lord's Prayer 5: "And Lead Us Not Into Temptation, But Deliver Us From Evil"



Scripture can be found here...

Here’s a question for today: Do we trust God? Is God trustworthy?

I’ll be honest. Arriving at the last petition in the Lord’s Prayer, here’s my first thought. Every one of us hearing or praying it would be totally justified in saying, “Wait. Hold on. Just a minute there. Are we actually praying with the understanding that God might lead us into temptation? And so we are just going to give God a little reminder, a little nudge, that, we’re not really so cool with that? What on earth is this all about?”

I recall learning the Lord’s Prayer as a little girl. I remember how this line in the prayer frightened me: “Lead us not into temptation, but deliver us from evil.” I remember sensing a kind of implicit threat that this request was attempting to ameliorate. It made God seem so menacing. It made God seem so unpredictable, so untrustworthy.

Do we really think that God is not trustworthy? In his “Institutes of the Christian Religion,” John Calvin provides one possible definition of faith: “…[Faith] is a firm and sure knowledge of the divine favor toward us, founded on the truth of a free promise in Christ, and revealed to our minds, and sealed on our hearts, by the Holy Spirit.”[i] In theory, at least, at the heart of faith is a “firm and sure knowledge of divine favor towards us.” We claim confidently that God loves us, that God wants what is best for us, that God wants us to thrive. So why on earth would God even consider “leading us into temptation?”

A peek at the language can help. You may have noticed today that I read the Authorized Version of our scripture (also known as the King James translation). Or you may not have noticed, since it is identical to the Lord’s Prayer as we pray it together week after week. The New Revised Standard Version, on the other hand, has a different slant, and a more accurate word-for-word translation: “Do not bring us to the time of trial, but rescue us from the evil one.” To me, and I’m willing to bet, to most of us, “temptation” and “trial” may be related, but they are still two distinctly different things. The Merriam-Webster definition of “temptation” is “the act of tempting or the state of being tempted, especially to evil; enticement.” “Trial,” on the other hand, is “the action or process of trying or putting to the proof; test;” or even, “a test of faith, patience, or stamina through subjection to suffering or temptation.” The word “temptation” suggests a God who might be inclined to entice us to sin. The word “trial” suggests a God who wants to see what stuff we are made of.

The better translation suggests that there might be times God would try us, or test us. This is still not a palatable notion. For one thing, it comes into conflict with all sorts of other things we believe about God—that God loves us, that God wills only the good for us, that God is there encouraging us and strengthening us. It also comes into conflict with the idea that God is omniscient. The psalmist prays,

O Lord, you have searched me and known me.
You know when I sit down and when I rise up; you discern my thoughts from far away.
You search out my path and my lying down, and are acquainted with all my ways.
Even before a word is on my tongue, O Lord, you know it completely.  ~Psalm 139:1-4

Why would God, having such complete understanding and intimate knowledge of our hearts, feel the need to test us anyway? Under this scenario God comes off as a kind of insecure lover, checking our emails, stealing a glance at our text messages, to make sure our hearts are true.

Still wondering about this whole notion of God “testing” us, we can turn to scripture, and see whether there are any instances of God testing God’s people. And, wow. There’s a pretty big one. I present, for your consideration, Matthew 4:1: “Then Jesus was led up by the Spirit into the wilderness to be tempted by the devil.” Not only are we pretty confident that God loved Jesus and was on Jesus’ side. Here we have the witness of scripture telling us, pretty unequivocally, that God ‘put Jesus to the test.’

But let’s look closer, to see exactly what God was up to when God handed Jesus over to be tested. Here are the exact temptations: First, Jesus is tempted to break his 40-day fast by miraculously changing stones into bread. This is a temptation to use the power of God, not fur others, but for himself, and in a showy display as well. Second, Jesus is tempted to throw himself off the pinnacle of the Temple, testing to see whether God would send angels to catch him. This is a temptation to put God to the test. And third, Jesus is offered all the kingdoms of the world and their splendor in return for worshipping the tempter-devil himself. This is a temptation to gain worldly riches and power in return for abandoning worship of the one true God.

So let’s be very clear about what constituted Jesus’ testing, about the temptations God allowed to be placed in his way. God was not exposing Jesus to the Ancient Near Eastern equivalent of girlie magazines, nor was God trying to get Jesus to cheat on his diet with a Bloomin’ Onion or a Sweet Frog sundae. God was permitting a test of Jesus’ most basic spiritual orientation. Had Jesus fully placed himself in God’s care and power? Was Jesus willing to use the power of God for impressive display or self-preservation or even enrichment? These are not trivial matters. When we pray, Do not lead us to the time of trial, I would suggest that we are, in effect, remembering the trial of Jesus in the wilderness, we are remembering the allure of power and wealth and the tradeoffs that put self-interest above the service of others. I would suggest that we are trembling in the face of that recollection, and praying that we might not be tested as Jesus was tested. We when pray, Do not lead us to the time of trial, I would suggest that we are reminding ourselves of Jesus’ complete and utter union with God, dependence on God, trust in God, and remembering that that is where the answer to temptation and testing can be found.

“Deliver us from evil,” we pray, or, “Rescue us from the evil one.” Oh, to have an instantaneous snapshot of the images that pop into all our heads when we pray those words. What comes into your head when you hear “evil,” or “deliver us from evil,” or “rescue us from the evil one”? As a child, I had a child’s picture of the devil—pitchfork, pointy tail, horns on his head, the whole deal. But in our age of hyperbole and fiery rhetoric, it’s open season on pretty much all well-known individuals, and the word “evil” is part of our arsenal. There are staggeringly large numbers of Americans who literally believe our President is the Anti-Christ, and therefore evil. The word “evil” has been applied to individuals, groups, and items as disparate as the Aurora and Sandy Hook shooters, Osama bin Laden, Wayne LaPierre, the members of Westboro Baptist Church, the Harry Potter books, Nancy Pelosi, and Rush Limbaugh. And the list goes on. Some of these names we can probably all agree with. Several would cause real disagreement, even here, in this loving community of faith. With the use of the word “evil” applied to such a startlingly wide array, there is a legitimate question that can be raised: Is “evil” a useful word? Or has it lost its meaning?

There are philosophers and psychologists who would argue that no person is evil; rather, actions are evil. Adolph Hitler, for example, would be described as a deeply disturbed, psychologically damaged individual who was responsible for unspeakably evil actions. But this leaves us somewhat unsatisfied, because it places our whole notion of justice in jeopardy. If people are not evil, then we are on the hook to try to help them. We can’t punish them in the way we would like if they are damaged or flawed.

What are we praying when we pray “deliver us from evil” or “rescue us from the evil one”? What if we looked again to those things used to test Jesus? Can we define evil as anything that causes us to turn away from God, or threatens to replace God as our first love? Can we recognize evil in anything that tempts us to use our power to harm others, or causes us to withhold our help to others? Is “evil” anything that stands in the way of love?

If you were to place the King James (i.e., our familiar) version of the Lord’s Prayer side by side with the version in your pew bible, you would notice a glaring omission: “For Thine is the kingdom, and the power and the glory, forever. Amen.” This closing doxology—this statement of praise—is something that was typically added on to the end of Christian prayers in the 17th century. It is not found in the original Greek of the Lord’s Prayer, because Jesus apparently didn’t say it. But, oh, he certainly implied it. From the opening words of the prayer, invoking a God in heaven and on earth; a God whose name is all holiness; a God whose kingdom is already unfolding in and all around us; a God who is the giver of all that is good; a God who forgives and forgives; a God who is trustworthy…every line of the prayer leads us to this closing ascription of praise, this closing statement of the reality of what is. We pray to God, that we will honor who God is, and that, steeped in that knowledge, we will get through this day, and our final words must recognize the deep truth. Everything that is, comes from God.

We can trust in God. This does not mean that we will not experience our own times of trial and testing. My own belief is that God does not put us to the test, but does allow life to do that. We can and do experience ourselves to be in the midst of challenges that make us wonder where we will find the strength to go on.

This afternoon a bunch of Union Presbyterians will climb into cars and trucks and vans for the trip to the Jersey Shore, to help with the effort to rebuild homes damaged by ‘Superstorm’ Sandy. Two years ago, and seven years ago, it was our own homes and basements and lives that were inundated with disastrous flooding. But the sorrows and tragedies that change our lives are not necessarily the stuff of headlines and wall-to-wall CNN coverage. We, all of us, suffer losses, some well known and some in the quiet of our own homes.

And still: we can trust in God. If all these losses and challenges are times of testing and trial, the Lord’s Prayer shows us where we find that strength to go on. We find it in God, and we find it in one another. We find it in the future hope of God’s vision—God’s great cleanup of the whole world—and we find it in the grace of God’s daily provision—weeping in one another’s arms, breaking our daily bread together, working side by side, and praying, praising, affirming that the kingdom and the power and the glory are God’s. Thanks be to God. Amen. Amen. Yes, it will be so. Amen.


[i] John Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion, III.2.vii, http://www.ccel.org/ccel/calvin/institutes.v.iii.html.